Running in the Fat-Burning Zone: Is it the Ideal Technique?
Categories: Advice, Health, Fitness, Fit Family Guy
Print
Some run for the pure enjoyment of it, some like to engage in competition, and others see it as a proven method of not looking like the Michelin Man. For many people, including me, it is a combination of these reasons. I'll confess that I'm forever pursuing more abdominal definition, which isn't easy for a beer-loving guy in his forties. While watching what I eat is important, it's the many kilometres of running each week that gives me a visible "four pack."
If you want to succeed at running long-term it's critical to love what you're doing and not just think of it as a means to an end. Realistically, however, many of us want to look good and running is one of the best calorie-burning exercises around. I can do a better job of loving it when I know it's helping eliminate some of the beer and pizza I inhaled the night before. So, what is the best way to run if you want to shed pounds? There are a few caveats such as your level of ability and preventing injury, but once you take those things into consideration the advice is simple: run as fast as you can for as long as you can.
There you go. Class dismissed.
On second though, let's bust one of the most popular myths about using aerobic exercise to burn fat.
Myth: The best way to burn fat is to keep your heart rate in the "fat burning zone"
This is true, but completely irrelevant. Yes, you do "oxidize" more body fat at moderate intensity levels and burn more carbohydrate fuel at higher intensities, but think of your energy stores as one big soup and it all comes out as a wash.
If you've ever seen a heart rate chart on a treadmill then you've read "fat-burning zone" at a moderate heart rate (about 60 percent of maximum) and "cardiovascular training zone" at a higher rate (75 percent of maximum or greater). Those charts aren't lying, but neither do they tell the full story. In a 2005 article in the European Journal of Sport Science, researchers measured fat burning oxidation rates at levels of intensity ranging from 25 percent to 85 percent of VO2peak (85% of VO2peak = 90% of max heart rate) and determined that the highest level of fat oxidation was at 65 percent intensity. Fat burning became "negligible" at intensities above 85 percent because at the highest intensities we burn mostly carbohydrates for fuel. These facts lead many to believe that exercising at a moderate intensity causes enhanced fat burning. While technically factual, it ignores the bigger picture.
Ironically, fat loss is not about using fat for fueling activity; it is calories in vs. calories out, which needs to be viewed from the perspective of what is called the 24-hour energy balance. If your energy balance is negative (more calories burned than consumed) weight is lost; if your energy balance is positive weight is gained. Yes, you may use more body fat for fuel while exercising at a moderate intensity, but in the grand scheme of the 24-hour energy balance equation this means nothing. If you exercise to create an overall negative energy balance you are going to burn those fat stores at some point in the day, whether you happen to be eating, sleeping, working or have wild and crazy trapeze sex (Giggity). The fact that the ratio of fat burned during moderate exercise was higher for fat than carbohydrates doesn't matter.
Having time to exercise is an important issue for many people. If you have 40 minutes in your schedule and want to maximize calories burned then pick the fastest pace you can handle for that duration of time. If you've ample time this equation changes to a balancing act of finding a challenging yet sustainable level of intensity – Bircher's aforementioned research found the most total calories were burned at a 75 percent intensity level. And if fat loss is your goal, then it is total calories that you are worried about. A 1998 article in the Journal of the American College of Clinical Nutrition found that sustained high-intensity exercise was far better at decreasing body-fat content than exercising at lower intensities.
It's important to note that metabolism increases on a sliding scale the higher the intensity, so you burn more calories running five kilometres than walking or slow jogging those same five km (and in less time). There are other great reasons to run at a higher intensity: It improves your overall cardiovascular fitness level making you more capable in other sports and it is better at boosting HDL (good) cholesterol.
To conclude, the best pace to run at is the one you like the most – the pace that keeps you lacing up those shoes. Just don't be afraid to incrementally push your limits if you want to burn more calories and therefore lose more fat.
James S. Fell is a Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist and a middle-aged family man with a desk job and not much free time, yet he's able to keep in shape because he loves exercise and doesn't mind eating healthy. He is the author of Body for Wife: The Family Guy's Guide to Getting in Shape. His column for That's Fit.ca focuses on weightlifting, running and exercise motivation.
Recent Posts
- Weight Loss and Alcohol: Is Extra-Light Beer a Better Choice? (7/30/2010)
- The Importance of Friends, Pregnancy Eating, Loving Your Body... (7/30/2010)
- Baby on the Way? Get Your Arms in Shape for Baby-Holding Marathons (7/30/2010)
- How to Be Happier in 30 Days: Release Your Fear (7/30/2010)
- Nutritious Green Beans Are Now in Season... (7/29/2010)







Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Daniel 3-02-2010 @ 10:15AM
here are my views.
i enjoy running, but do i!!!!!!!! no, absolutely not. do i miss it? little bit. Why don't i start running again if i miss it a little? very simply put, one should run with a purpose and so many don't have a purpose or the wrong one.
you a involved in sport, you should train your cardio in regards to your sport, that rarely happens. you are training to "get in shape". in shape for what? if it is for you health, then walking does a much better job and here is why.
most people get injured running, because they are not strong enough for their own body weight. so what do you think happen overtime after hours and hours of pounding!!!! also, most people do not know how to run, just like most people do not know how to train. you want to "get in shape! Get conditioned first, then you can get in shape".
some people run to improve their heart/stronger heart! well guys that i am not so sure. you want a stronger heart... get to the gym and start working out - Strength Training, i mean real strength training.
what about weight loss? strength training, with the right application - nutrition, rest, an achievable goal...- is what you are after.
Mr. Fell mentioned something about increasing metablism. here is my belief on this one. You do not increase metabolism, you can only improve it to where it should be at peak performance level and it will be different from person to person.
so, your best weight loss solution, and this is me belief and i do it regularly; very minimal cardio and at very light intensity, strength training, good nutrition, rest, and achievable goal and a truly positive attitude.
sincerely
Reply
Kris 3-02-2010 @ 11:18AM
My trainer told me an easy way to figure out if you're working hard enough.... If you can carry on a conversation, but don't want to, then you're getting your heart rate up high enough. I guess that's the low end of the cardio scale....
Thoughts?
Reply