Are Control Issues Sabotaging Your Relationship?
Categories: Love & Relationships, Advice
PrintAre Control Issues Sabotaging Your Relationship?">
Are you one of those women who plays Superwoman while your husband takes a back seat? Dr. Carin Rubenstein, a psychologist and author of The Superior Wife Syndrome: Why Women Do Everything So Well And Why -- For the Sake of Our Marriages -- We've Got to Stop, says that this arrangement is bad for your marriage.Q: What is the "Superior Wife Syndrome"?
A: The Superior Wife Syndrome is what happens when we, meaning wives, get in the driver's seat and allow our husbands to get in the back and coast. It's what happens when we do all the thinking, cooking, bill paying and child caring because we think we can do it better. We take control and, whether it's conscious or not, it's something that happens in two out of every three marriages.
Q: Is it a relatively recent phenomenon?
A: It's recent in the last couple of decades. It used to be, back in the 1950s and 1960s, "Father Knows Best" time. Men were considered the head of the household, period. But now that women are in the workforce and earning their own living, it's much more common for wives to be the ones who do all of the thinking and all of the planning -- they basically run the household.
Q: How does this make marriage more difficult?
A: It's bad for marriage. It makes wives resentful and irritable when it comes to their husbands. Wives end up not having a partner, but another child. That's no way to run a good marriage. Husbands might think they get off easy by having a wife who does everything, but that's not the case. When you have a resentful wife, you have a wife who's unhappy and who doesn't want to have sex with you and who's depressed and maybe even nasty.
Q: How is control at odds with intimacy?
A: An intimate bond is one where you trust each other and share pretty much everything that can be shared. When there's one person who's monopolizing all of the control in the marriage, that's a very unequal balance and it's very hard to have an intimate relationship when things are so out of sync. And I think it's natural for wives to resent a partner who's not really a true partner. When you get that resentment, the intimate bond is gone.
Q: How do men with Superior Wives behave?
A: Men with superior wives wait for their dinner to be served, have someone who pays their bills and have somebody who deals with their children all of the time, except for the rare occasions when they are asked to deal with the children themselves. Their day-to-day life might seem easier because their job is to have a job and that's about it. Sometimes their job is to mow the lawn and change the oil in the cars. In many cases, they're content to relinquish control. I'm not saying that this is a conscious decision on both parts -- it's something that often just happens to people. We know from research that when couples get married, they expect two things: that the wives will continue to work, and that they will share all of the household chores. This ends up true for the first little bit, but almost as soon as children are born, that goes completely out the window. This happens slowly over time, but as soon as the children arrive they're considered the wife's job and it permeates their entire lives. Suddenly, a couple looks up after five years of marriage and nothing is as equal as they thought it would be when they got married.
Q: So do Superior Wives need to demand more of their spouses?
A: I'm not sure I would put it that way. Unfortunately, the onus is on them to fix this, too, just as the onus is on them to do everything else. They have to learn to expect less from themselves, to be less than they can be. And they have to set different standards; not "Would you do the dishes tonight?" but "Someone has to do the dishes and someone has to give the kids a bath; which one would you prefer to do?" They have to devise ways for their husbands to step up to the plate and then let go of their need to supervise.
Q: Any other tips for avoiding or fixing this issue?
A: I think more and more women are avoiding it by postponing marriage, but we know that most women do eventually marry at some point. If you're not married yet, just knowing that this is likely to happen in your marriage may help you prevent it, and if you're already in a marriage like this you need to talk to your husband about it. A lot of times, wives think their husbands have some kind of ESP and know how unhappy or resentful their wives are -- but that simply is not the case.
Recent Posts
- Think Opposites Attract? Not When Choosing Your Spouse (9/03/2010)
- Rev Up Your Run, Butt Toning Tips and More (9/03/2010)
- How To Get That Workout Rush (9/03/2010)
- Are You Using Your Intuition? (9/03/2010)
- Split Routines: Find the Weightlifting Program That's Right For You (9/03/2010)

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
eric geis 11-19-2009 @ 10:06AM
The tone of the article is heavily biased in the achknowledgement of women's (inherent) superiority. Even when they can "do it all", they are to deliberately do less.
There was no discussion of the situation where the wife thinks she can "do it better" across the board and in some situations does not do it better. Trying to get some compromise, to get her to acknowledge that her way is not always the best or even only way, is frequently difficult.
One area where there is an unlevel playing field is in parenting. If the wife has one approach ( in my situation, very accomodating of the kids) and my approach is more of requiring the kids to have much more personal responsibility, sparks do fly frequently. My wife does all of the thinking for the children, the older daughter does not have to know her schedule, even the day of the week. "Mom" micromanages every detail and all the daughter has to do is barely be ready on time. This morning she had to be told three times to pick up her back pack on the way out the door.
I believe that the tendency of Moms to micro manage the family details stunts the kids' development. Yes, it does make it easier for "Mom" to make all events go off on schedule, but the kids do not learn that there are consequences for lack of preparation.
It seems that some Moms extend the micro management of the kids to include all family events and the husbands allow it to happen to avoid conflicts. Why should I try to insert my self into the process when it probably will be my wife doing the transport? I have seen situations where the Mom wants the control to know her schedule. She makes all of the minute to minute changes and juggles the balls. With two people, the cell phones would never cool off.
I think the parents have to be partners. They have to share duties, and be willing to ask to help. If I am near the market, I'll call to ask if she wants to add anything to my list, or if near the daycare at the end of day, I'll call to see if she wants me to get the 3 year old, etc. Just going in the same direction at the same time is not a team.
There have to be shared goals and objectives. The parents have to sit down at least once a week to go over the upcoming schedules in writing to avoid "memory games" (I TOLD you about that.) where masses of minutia are exchanged and each has to try to not only remember but understand the implication of each item. The objective should be to communicate so as to get full "buy in" and maximum performance from the partner.
Sadly, I have failed to achieve this in my marriage.
Eric
Reply
Christy 11-19-2009 @ 3:09PM
Eric,
I whole-heartedly agree that many women (and perhaps to lesser degree, men) are simply uncomprimising in their relationships and childrearing/discipline of the children. I believe that this behavior causes so much conflict and creates a 'dualistic', she verses he, dynamic that always diminishes and leaves one person out of the 'co-creation' aspect that is so important in any healthy relationship.
At the end of the article, the interviewee does mention that women need to relinquish the need to 'supervise' everything and allow men to do whatever it is in their own way, without the constant, 'here's how I do it' which is absolutely belittling to anyone.
I have no children, but I am happily married (14 years this December). I consider my husband an equal partner in all aspects of our relationship and with that said, I have always strived to keep the lines of communication with that dynamic in mind. There are times when we need to re-negotiate our roles/responsibilities within our relationship based on new developments or simply the evolution of our individual wants/needs.
Women also need to start taking responsibility for the relationship dynamic that they may inadvertently be creating. Self-awareness is the beginning of that change that needs to take place for their to be a beautiful, peaceful co-existence between husband and wife. Unfortunately, too many people are not willing to look at their own role in the demise of their situation.
Just my thoughts...