Don't Screen Out All the Sun
Categories: Health
PrintHere's another goodie from The Healthy Foodie's archives.
Well, summer is finally starting to show it's face, or at least giving us a little hint of things to come, so I figured I should talk about sunscreen. But I had to stop and ponder before doing this post. I get accused, from time to time, of fear-mongering and promoting an "everything is going to kill you" attitude. I don't mean to come across this way and I'm trying to, perhaps, soften my delivery a bit. The fact is, I don't feel everything is going to kill you. Quite the opposite, in fact. I simply feel that we've gotten ourselves into a situation here on planet Earth where the "bottom line" is valued over and above what is best for the planet and it's inhabitants. As a result, it's necessary for us, as consumers, to stay aware of the dangers that exist out there and how we can best avoid them.
That being said, your sunscreen is going to kill you.
Heh, just kidding. But again, we have a situation here where an industry has grown around a particular ingredient that we later find out is toxic and should be avoided. The Centers for Disease Control in the U.S. published a study in March that has shown that a toxic chemical in many sunscreens called oxybenzone, linked to allergies, hormone disruption and cell damage, is present in 97% of Americans.
What's more, oxybenzone, also known as benzophenone-3, is a component of 84% of the 910 sunscreens examined by the Environmental Working Group (EWG), a non-profit organization based in Washington D.C. who work to inform the public of harmful products and to make policy change in Washington. Check out the site EWG have created called Skin Deep which is a cosmetics safety database. It rates sunscreens and other cosmetics on the safety of their ingredients and the effectiveness of the products themselves. A truly valuable resource.
And while we're on the topic of sunscreen we should look at the nature of the beast itself. Sunscreen does what it's name suggests - it blocks the sun from reaching your skin. This is for the purpose of preventing skin damage in the form of sunburn or, more severely, skin cancer. But one of the problems with blocking the sun is that sun exposure is necessary in order to produce vitamin D. Vitamin D is made by the body when ultraviolet radiation from sunlight reacts with the cholesterol in your skin (that's right - you need cholesterol to make vitamin D). Sunblock stops, or at the very least decreases this reaction from occurring, possibly resulting in Vitamin D deficiency. (It should be pointed out, however, that this is a controversial statement. It is currently hotly debated as to whether sunscreen has a significant effect on vitamin D production - some doctors claim it does while the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) maintains it's stance that sunscreen does not significantly reduce vitamin D production. Of course the majority of AAD officers have financial ties to sunscreen manufacturers. I'll let you be the judge on that one).
Ironically, research is now linking low levels of vitamin D to cancer. New research out of Germany published in the Carcinogenesis medical journal found that women with low levels of vitamin D in their blood had a significantly greater risk of contracting breast cancer. Other studies have found vitamin D supplementation to significantly cut risk of colon cancer, ovarian cancer and prostate cancer. Dr. Edward Giovannucci, MD told National Public Radio's Patricia Neighmond that an estimated 30 people may die of cancers related to vitamin D deficiency for every one who dies from skin cancers caused by excessive sun exposure.
Now, I'm not suggesting that you stop using sunscreen altogether and go and hang out in the sun all day. There are many products listed on the EWG site I posted above that are safe and effective and you obviously want to stay protected from burns. What I am suggesting is moderate sun exposure. Many would have you believe that any amount of sunshine is going to increase your risk of cancer. Sunlight is the source of all life on the planet. Hiding yourself away from it is counter to life. To me this seems like common sense.
If you find that you're burning with very minimal sun exposure, you may need to increase the antioxidants in your diet. Certain antioxidants, particularly astaxanthin found in microalgae, yeast, salmon, trout, some shell fish and crustaceans, boost your body's natural resistance to UV damage. Along these lines, researchers at the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine have found that the application of an extract from broccoli sprouts will increase the body's natural defenses against UV skin damage, providing increased protection from the sun without blocking vitamin D production. Perhaps this is where the future of sunscreens are heading. Dr. Joseph Mercola of mercola.com fame recommends making sure the ratio of omega 6 to omega 3 fats consumed be as close to 1:1 as is possible (most North Americans consume closer to a 15:1 ratio) in order to prevent melanoma without applying any sunscreen which he strongly advises against using.
So this week, rather than more of the "everything is going to kill you" philosophy, I'm telling you something that is not going to kill you - sun. 15 minutes at a time during the day of unprotected sun exposure, outside of the sun's peak hours from 10 - 2, should be enough to keep you healthy without letting you burn. But also keep in mind that the darker the natural pigment of your skin, the more sun exposure you need to get sufficient vitamin D production. People with darker skin need, on average, 6 times more sun exposure than those with fairer skin to make the same amount of vitamin D.
The Healthy Foodie is Doug DiPasquale, Holistic Nutritionist and trained chef, living in Toronto. You can email him with questions at dugdeep@gmail.com.
Recent Posts
- Nutritious Green Beans Are Now in Season... (7/29/2010)
- Demi's Defensive Diet, Tips For Eating Out and More (7/29/2010)
- How Yoga Can Make You Stronger (7/29/2010)
- Soy Debate: Why Do Health Practitioners Never Agree? (7/29/2010)
- You Can Choose How You Deal With Stress (7/29/2010)







Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Teresa 5-21-2008 @ 10:57AM
Hello Doug.. Great article, if you are not like me and very fair skinned and very blonde and very - go to the hospital after being oceanside for 30 minutes with no suncreen. I am teased about burning by the dashboard lights or the glow of the moon. I have used sunscreen in some for or other my whole life ( 50yrs) started with and still count on zinc ointment al the way to SPF 55 sunblocks. Recent bllodtests show my vitamin D levels as great. By the way the air in parts of Ontario contains more carcinogens than sunscreen..Maybe if we all stop breathing???
Reply
ROY WELDON 5-21-2008 @ 11:19AM
A very timely article--------- making the general public
aware is essential, you are correct ref "bottom line"
profit has no time for planet or people!
Reply
Mark 5-21-2008 @ 7:19PM
This guy is a complete idiot.
Reply
Mrs McIntyre 5-21-2008 @ 8:11PM
Very interesting article. I use sunscreen with common sense, if I figure Im gonna burn out there, I put it on or stay indoors. Just like bug repellent, if Im in a mosquitoe infested area, I use Off, or I just dont go. Moderation is the key I would think.
Reply
Stella 5-21-2008 @ 9:19PM
Growing up we played outside -babies were given sunbaths for a short time, not in the noonday sun.
We played in and out of the sun /shade.
Now people bake on the beaches etc - trying to get a good suntan -no matter what.
Sunscreen seemed a good idea -more for big business than for the health of the consumer.
There are Very Big Dollars to be made - Out of our Pocket into coffers. - not a great concern for the safety of consumers.
People in Tropical countries -manage to live with the sun.
A Little Common Sense - is what we need.
Reply
JasperPants 5-21-2008 @ 10:04PM
Be aware of the source - EWG is a radical enviro-group.
Not necessarily proof the report is bunk, but buyer beware applies.
Reply
s.j. 5-23-2008 @ 11:25AM
well, I'm screwed. I eat soya and use sunblock! Is there anything out there that isn't harmful to us? I take multi vitamins with vitamin d.. so hope that buys me some time!
s.j.
Reply
Nick 7-04-2008 @ 2:20PM
I think that information is wonderful and how we choose to use it is up to us... I personally burn like crazy when I apply sunscreen as directed... when I don't have the sunscreen on I tend to burn but nowhere near as badly. I think that the content of the message is useful but we all know our own bodies and these messages that are sent are meant to be helpful. Take it and use it how you wish to.
Reply